Pages

Thursday, September 13, 2012

Sunday, October 16, 2011

Differentiation: No Different, Even With Tracking

In advising teachers about how to group kids for differentiated instruction, Carol Ann Tomlinson provides three axes to think about:  interest, ability and readiness.  I used to think that mixed ability groups were always the best, but after reading her book and hearing her speak, I realize that different situations call for different types of grouping.  So, last year, I used homogenous grouping more often than I had in the past.  I think it was a good idea.  Normally, in heterogeneous groups, when one student is more able to complete the task, she or he usually tells the partner the answer.  So, the partner doesn't really learn.  I liked the homogenous grouping because I think it was helpful for two students to struggle together with the cognitive task. Of course, this falls apart when neither student is engaged and they do little without me working with them.

This year, our scheduling has resulted in meta-homogenous grouping:  For several years, the kids who score advanced in math and English were automatically plucked from regular classes and dropped into GATE classes.  But now, the kids remaining in the regular pool at our school are being tracked into classes based largely on their CST scores (with a little bit of wiggle room based on grades).  The more advanced kids get an intervention class called "Humanities" and the less advanced kids are programmed into "Academic Literacy."

This felt like tracking to me and I was immediately opposed to it.

The two "Humanities" groups I have are some of the most motivated and dedicated students I have ever had. And, most are better able to persist with cognitively difficult tasks, instead of opting out by distracting themselves and each other.  Those that do get easily distracted or don't consistently persist still do better than they did last year in regular classes because the class culture this year is more serious about school. That means the kids more likely to give up quickly, feel peer pressure to persist in the class longer.  That's good, but not surprising.

I didn't know what to expect from the other two groups of kids I have: the "Academic Literacy" groups.  What I am finding is that this grouping seems to be more of a mixed bag.  The positive is that it is easier for me to teach this group, and I think easier for them to learn, because everyone is generally at the same level in terms of reading ability.  That means I can provide more scaffolding for this group and go a little slower.

But, like any other class I have had, teaching to the middle doesn't serve the needs of the kids at the edges of the spectrum.  So, differentiation is still necessary.  I have some super motivated, very strong readers - who I would love to put into a Humanities class, but cannot for reasons too numerous to explain here.  And, I have super unmotivated students, and students with very low reading skills that require a lot of support.

But, what is better, is that the spectrum of abilities is compressed. The kids outside the middle are not as far outside (in both directions) than I have seen them before this year's new grouping.  So, it is much easier for me to scale up or scale down, depending on the student.

Still, I realize that my experience is different than other teachers.  I don't have any kids that are Far Below Basic on the CST, that test I abhor so much.  They just happen to be in another "Academic Literacy" class.  I suspect that those classes are harder to teach because they have more students who:

  1. Have scored FBB because they rationally decided to opt out of a schooling system that doesn't serve their needs or honor who they are as individuals,
  2. Have undiagnosed learning disabilities,
  3. Have large gaps in their learning and really need some extra support, 
  4. All of the above
I can't speak to the experience of those teaching this group.  But, for me, I am trying to take advantage of the groupings I have and try to get my students to learn as much as possible. 

Monday, October 10, 2011

The classroom blogs we started last week seem to be going pretty well.  Students are signing into them and posting.  Most are mostly following the guidelines (using Standard English, not tampering with the dashboard - actually, I haven't educated them yet about the dashboard, so only the truly clever and curious can do any damage).

I see three main purposes for the class blogs at this point.
  1. Discussion of class novels
  2. A place for me to post the day's assignments 
  3. A venue to eventually differentiate instruction by giving different students different assignments, like this one, using the concept Youssef taught us, "View Only and Make a Copy."
Now that I am using Blogger (and thinking about a Wiki), I have so many more questions than I did during our summer training.  I guess that's what happens when you move from theory into practice.  I know my kids are enjoying this, but I don't think I'd bother if I wasn't enjoying it, too.  I am having so much fun.

Wednesday, October 5, 2011

Blogging in Class: Taking the Plunge

Today, my students and I took the plunge into blogs. Well, into commenting on blogs.  I created one for each of my four groups of kids.  Today's goal was to learn how to comment.

Snapshots
By the time my last class came along, I knew I should explain what a blog was before having them just log in.  When I showed it to them, in all its color and grandeur, they gasped, "That's our blog?" They were really impressed with its design.  One of the many things about middle schoolers is that for all their cynicism and complaining, they do still have a sens of awe.  I love impressing them with things like ready-made templates. 

Quotes
"Look, it says we can even make our own blogs!  And it's free!" 

Takeaways
It is really important to get the permissions set right.  I gave this a lot of thought, and spoke to several other teachers and tech folks.  I decided to let them post anonymously (to avoid creating Google accounts).  Mistake.  In answer to the question, "What's your favorite book or movie," here were the most creative responses:








It sounds worse than it was.  I thought it was pretty funny that this poster (or these posters) figured out how to make their classmates laugh without getting caught.  Most comments were great, of course.  I have a great group of kids.





Final Thoughts
A teacher can't just walk in and say, "OK, let's blog."  I like to have things thought-out, organized and systematized so my students have a good experience. Links that don't work, frustration logging in, and laptops that aren't charged can easily undermine a lesson.  But, today reminded me there is much I can't anticipate.  Students' reactions and responses quickly reveal the holes in lesson plans.  Scrambling to reset the permissions at lunch was the right thing to do.